Garden Botanika is one of the brands that seems to consistently put out lip products that I like. I recently got a Garden Botanika Slip Gloss in a sample box from My Pretty Pink Box (read review on Beauty and Fashion Tech).
Garden Botanika’s gloss is wonderfully smooth. It is absolutely non-sticky and has a high shine with good tint. I truly love it. With Meadowfoam Oil and Shea Butter, it also moisturizes quite well.
The shade Cranapple (pictured), works well for me. It is not really as dark as the photo and is a nice neutral berry shade.
I often get Garden Botanika products at Ulta. You can also comparison shop for Garden Botanika at Shopzilla.